Barbara Cloyd's Songwriter Search

 

Home
Bio

Blog:Funk and Roll Diaries
Music
Buy CDs
Lyrics
Musical Influences
Reviews/Press clippings
Links
Friend me!
Contact

Songwriter Search Workshop

Date: Friday, September 19-21, 2003
Location: Bristol, Tennessee/Bristol, Virginia
Purpose: Barbara Cloyd's Songwriter Search Workshop

Barbara Cloyd’s Songwriter Search in Bristol, Tennessee

When I read the acceptance email to Barbara Cloyd’s Songwriter Search Workshop, I must admit, I got really excited…I’m talkin’ about “take your shoes off and dance a jig excited.”
You see, Barbara Cloyd books songwriters at Nashville’s famous Bluebird Cafe…in the songwriting community, the Bluebird Cafe is the most famous Songwriter venue…and, yes, it’s the same Bluebird Cafe that you see every Saturday night on Turner South (“Live at the BlueBird Cafe). If you haven’t heard about the Bluebird Cafe, check out Janis Ian’s article about the famous Bluebird audition process.

Barbara started the Songwriter Search Workshops to help Nashville publishers connect with talented writers outside of Nashville. To be selected, songwriters must submit 3 original songs, which are judged by Barbara based on the merits of the song, not the recording. She selects 15 to 20 songwriters to attend the workshop. At the workshops, Barbara matches select songwriters with established, successful music industry professionals. She seeks out industry contacts who have a passion for discovering new talent and who believe that looking beyond the Nashville scene can be a way find writers with a fresh, unique approach. You can read more about Barbara Cloyd’s Songwriter Search Workshops on her site.

I found out about the Songwriter Search Workshops through the Charlotte chapter of NSAI. Fellow songwriter, Skip Black, applied and was accepted to Barbara’s workshop a year ago…and he regailed our songwriting group with his tales of how it ultimately led to his cowriting songs with Nashville staff writers--songs that were now actually being pitched around Nashville.

As it turns out, a fellow Charlotte songwriter, Don Petty was accepted as well—so we both took time off from work to ride up to Bristol, TN together…(Don from his career as a hair stylist and me from my day job as a technical writer). We packed my New Beetle full of guitars and CDs took the mountain roads up to Bristol, TN.

We chatted the whole drive, discussing the current state of the music industry, what we expected from the weekend, which songs we would play at the weekend, how we felt about file sharing, what our musical goals are, etc. It was great to be able to spend some time with Don—I see him at our NSAI meetings, but we both have so many ideas, we can never seem to finish a conversation before the meeting’s over…

Anyway, we unpacked our suitcases in room 326 of the Comfort Inn, grabbed a bite to eat at the KFC buffet down the street, and gathered our CDs and business cards in preparation for meeting everyone at the first event. At 7:30 pm we met in the conference room at the Comfort Inn. The room was buzzing as the 20 songwriters who were selected for the workshop and the four music industry folks met each other over chips and beer. We spent the next three hours chatting, introducing ourselves, and listening to each other’s songs. It was great to hear everyone’s music for the first time, and, man, was there some cool stuff. I heard some great country, Americana, bluegrass, and even some true NY club music. Writers had traveled from all parts of the East Coast to be there. There were writers from New York, Kentucky, Tennessee, North Carolina, Florida, Illinois, Arkansas, etc.

We went around the room playing 1 song each. Some folks played live, but over half o the writers had demos on CD-R. When it was my turn, I played “Christmas in July” from my new CD One-Way Ticket. It was pretty far outside of the country “box”, but I saw a lot of smiles and heads bobbing…and several folks seemed pretty interested in what I was doing. I could tell, however, that I was gonna be way more rock and roll than the other writers…I just didn’t know how that would play out.

The “vibe” Friday night was really positive. I didn’t feel an ounce of competitive spirit…and I really felt a sense that we were all part of a little club…one where everyone enjoyed everyone else’s company…and we all wanted to help each other succeed. I knew the weekend would be very cool.

Friday night’s event was an “ice-breaker”…and the publishers were not allowed to critique the songs. As we mingled, I got a card from Karen Reynolds who runs the “Writer’s Block” radio show on 89.9 WDVX, a listener-funded station in Knoxville, TN. She asked me to send her a CD so she could play some of my music on her show…how cool is that? It’s simulcast on the web and sounds like a really cool show, so you may want to check it out at http://www.wdvx.com.

After a couple of beers and some mingling, everyone headed back to their rooms to prepare for the early morning bus ride…

Listen to Brian's music now!

Saturday Workshop Events

Saturday morning, the big white school bus took us into downtown Bristol for our day-long songwriting critique session.

What’s Bristol like?

When we arrived at the theatre, the mayor of Bristol, VA welcomed us (even though we were in TN at the time)...and told us how Bristol was the home of country music. It seems that the first recording device in the area (1927, I think) was set up by a local who used it to make the first Carter family recordings (among others). Those recordings are still in the Country Music Hall of fame in Nashville.

If you’ve never been there, Bristol is located on the border between Tenessee and Virginia--the state line actually runs right through the center of downtown...so there's a Bristol, TN and a Bristol, VA. Each town has separate fire departments, police departments, mayors, tax structures, etc. Both towns were sponsoring the "Rhythm and Roots Music Festival" that weekend, complete with live country and bluegrass music and street vendors. We spent our time Saturday in the coolest old theatre right in the middle of the festival...during our breaks, we could walk out and enjoy the festival…where the street vendors were a bit disgruntled about the festival food cart having a monopoly on hamburgers, hotdogs, and soft drinks. (They found amusement, however, in the fact that the Virginia health inspector made the cart move to TN because of it’s open flame…where the TN health inspector found another health code violation…)

Songwriting Sessions

On Saturday, we spent from 9:00 am to 3 pm playing songs for the industry panel. After each song, each music industry professional gave us a critique—so each song got four critiques. Following a short break, we returned to a Q&A session with the panel that was open to the public.

I heard some pretty cool stuff from the other songwriters…but, I must admit, it was a bit tough to listen to the publishers pick apart the craft of each song all day—that’s 80 critiques! I dunno what I expected them to do really, but they certainly gave us an honest opinion…which was both great and disheartening. They would pick out lines that didn’t make sense to them, characters that acted “out of character”, songs written from the wrong point of view, and lines that could be “bettered”. They commented on craft and the marketability of each song. In short, they heard no hits.

When it was my turn, I played “Daily Grind”. It’s a song about how working in corporate America is stifling. In it, I use every complaint I’ve heard about a sucky office job. It’s one of my newer songs…it’s really punk rock-based. The panel seemed to like the song—especially the verses, but didn’t really know what I wanted from them. I guess that’s because my music is not designed for the mainstream Nashville market. I started to realize that my music center is not Nashville, but Los Angeles…something Jerry Vandiver told me a year ago…his words are still ringing through my ears…

The bus ride back to the hotel, surprisingly, wasn’t a quiet one. Everyone seemed a bit drained, but in good spirits. During the day, we had begun to develop relationships with the other writers…and, upon arriving back at the hotel, we were excited about meeting each other for dinner.

Don and I headed back up stairs to change, and as soon as we got to the room, Greg Valente burst in with his guitar, saying, “Let’s write a song”. We only had 30 minutes before dinner! Never one to turn down a challenge, I jumped right in…we were just starting to find the groove when it was time to leave for dinner.

Dinner was great! BIG BUFFET at the Golden Corral. Yeah, baby. How can that be bad?? (My dad would be so proud!) We had table of 15 songwriters or so (including Barbara), and we spent the time laughing, talking, and sharing music stories. It was great!

After dinner, most of the songwriters gathered in the conference room to jam…but Don and I decided to stay upstairs and write a song instead. This time, we made significant progress, fleshing out nearly the entire melody and chord changes. To wind down, we stayed up late talking about the day…

Sunday

Sunday was another intense day. We each had a song critiqued by the panel. By now, the industry panel knew who we were and what kind of music we wrote. In fact, they greeted us all by name as we left.

Sunday’s critiques were a little different. Because everyone had heard 3 of our songs by now, the industry panel seemed to summarize more instead of getting into the details of each song. They would offer guidance about what to do and where our music might find a home. For example, the songwriting team from Kentucky was praised for their great “old-school” country style, but were told that it wasn’t marketable in Nashville. Instead, they were advised to look to Texas, where bands and radio stations still had a circuit for that kind of music.
I played “Don’t Say No”, and was a bit disappointed when the panel didn’t seem to recognize the Pink Floyd and Beatles influence.

We used the last few minutes of our time together to thank the panel and Barbara, trade CDs and phone numbers, and wish their fellow bards the best…


Summary

I was really glad to have the opportunity to attend Barbara Cloyd’s Songwriter Search workshop. It was the first time that my music has been heard by big-time music publishers…and I learned a lot about how the music industry works. Barbara is SUPER nice, and incredibly insightful. If you’re a songwriter looking to get to the next level in Nashville, you should definitely check out what she’s doing!

Probably the best part of the weekend for me was meeting the other songwriters from around the country. Everyone was really talented, and super friendly. I traded music with several folks there, and plan to keep in touch with them.

I came away from the weekend tired and a bit confused. It took me a day or so to make sense of everything that happened. In the end, I realized that my “thing” is all about being “indie” and doing it yourself. I’m sticking to my guns, continuing to work towards selling 5,000 CDs. As for the industry, I don’t really believe in writing for their “box” of music…I believe in writing about what I feel—even if it’s not what they can sell. I learned my music is most appropriate for LA, not Nashville, so I plan to make a trip to the “other coast” to check out some film placement opportunities next year.


Listen to Brian's music now!